« A Modest Proposal to Save Journalism | Main | A Paradox of Public Education »

December 24, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83534ac5b69e201053698b96c970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Meaning of Christmas:

Comments

Joy

I agree with you when you say that the meaning of Christmas is often tied up in consumerism. Many people do not believe in the true meaning of Christmas. Celebrating Jesus birth. They do however participate in the consuming part. Our family, celebrating Christmas for what it is, a time to remember and reflect on Jesus' birth. We do exchange gifts but nothing big and expensive and definitely not always the latest and greatest that the consuming world has to offer. We try to keep our focus on what we consider the main thing. I also think Christmas is a time for family and friends to gather and a time of sharing and giving. It's hard to do that in an environment that is being overcome with greed and consumption. We need to get back to the main thing, whatever your main reason for celebrating Christmas is.

Lindsey Mcnally

I believe Christmas does not have to be someting about religion. Obviously it is based on christianity, at least here in the U.S..But thousands of people prove you do not need to have a religion to celebrate Christmas. To me it is just a time of year where you can be with one's family and do all the traditions you are use to doing on Christmas.

Tori Bodin

Of course the ties between Christmas and consumerism are obvious. Growing up my dad would start buying Christmas presents in January and hide them until December when he would brag that his shopping was done months ago.
Unlike my dad, I enjoy Christmas shopping and finding just the right presents for people I care about. Its nice to give them something that lets them know I know enough about them to stray from anything generic. Of course anyone who complains about receiving presents is lying as well, since there's always that one gift you didn't have the money to buy yourself, but are grateful to receive for Christmas.
However Christmas in America is certainly different than any other culture. Even Jewish families have invented Christmakkuh, in order to celebrate their religion and the Christmas season. My dad grew up in Sweden, and Christmas there was very different. Although there was plenty of celebration, it was for St. Lucia and gifts were given mostly to children and one to the family as a whole.
Today Christmas represents the American standard of living. Santa no longer makes dolls and trains for children, but instead ipods and Wiis. Christmas plays into the dominant culture by no longer seperating the good and the bad kids, but the rich and the poor. High culture has extravagent Christmas parties, complete with visits from Santa himself and a numerous number of presents for children who are just learning how to add. In most cases, the counterculture are those who reject Christmas because of its correlation to consumerism, usually just because they aren't the ones invited to the huge parties.
Still, there are those that still believe in the message of Christmas and those who even if they do not have significant faith, recognize its meaning. Christmas has become more centered around family than religion in a lot of cases, and I dont think that is a problem.

Molly McKinnon

CHRISTmas is a time to thank the lord for what he has done for the people on this earth and the day that he was born in Bethlehem. Christmas think that it is all about presents and material things. This is a time to forget all worries and the hatred that you have against people. For me and my family its about Jesus and prasing him. Christmas was about Jesus and his birthday and spending time with love ones. However, its not like that any more it has became a day about how much money can be spent and how quick you can open one present to get to the next. I believe the meaning of Christmas has been lost through out the years instead of being about love and sharing and family. Its all about how many hours you can spend in a store and how much money can you spend. It is so sad that we have got away from the true meaning of Christmas. Wouldn't it be nice to be able to give one gift and have a wonderful dinner and enjoy just being with your family instead of over spending and going in debt. well that is is my out look on what Christmas has became and most of you probably understand agree!

Taylor Kirchner

Nothing has meaning until you put meaning to it; all knowledge is transitory. People will put whatever meaning to this day. I have celebrated Christmas since I was born, not because I am religious (I have actually never been to Church) but because it is almost a folkway. People are expected to celebrate Christmas as long as you’re not part of a different religion. The religious day has now become a commercial holiday. There are ads on television, Christmas trees in lots, and stores filled with Christmas crap the day after Thanksgiving.
Along with Inniss, I really don’t know the whole story behind the holiday. I celebrate, if you can call it that, because I feel like I have to. However, my family doesn’t really do anything special. My dad may get me a little trinket and I give a hug (he never wanted me or my brother to get him anything.) The holiday still excites me as it did when I was a kid. I think of all reasons why my family celebrates it is, it gives us an excuse to all get together and eat dinner. I rreally can’t complain that the holiday does exist, I love the Christmas spirit around that time.

Marta

I completely agree when Janis says our country and world has twisted the true meaning of Christmas. I believe that this is a time that the Lord wanted us to focus on Jesus Christ's birthday celebration. It is a time to be with those you love, give, and celebrate Jesus' birth. Many have forgotten what the true meaning of christmas is. Just a few weeks ago in my sociology class, we were talking about how now people who live here in California are trying to decorate like they live in the UK. Decorations of trees that don't grow here, snow that doesn't fall here, and unchristian animals are set next to mangers. To me it seems like people now days get too caught up in the material life and forget why the day was made a holiday. I think we all need to rethink what the holiday means to us; whether it's about religion or just love we still need to think about what we portray it as.

Amanda

I realize that many people celebrate holidays, for example Christmas, not for religious purposes. I think though that it is fine to celebrate Christmas without any religious ceremonies. I feel the main reason why we celebrate Christmas is to be with family and spread the love and joy. Christmas for some people is a time to relax and be in peace with your loved ones. I think people should be able to celebrate however they wish as long as they are happy and are not interferring with other's happiness.

Ariana menchaca,


In this text, i liked it very much because it went in the meaning and how she felt deep inside how she truly sees Christmas. I think we all have given in to what the false meaning of this holiday is truly. I become to know that a Christmas is not about the gifts but there is a true meaning of Gods birth. I do agree with Janis when you say that the meaning of Christmas about consumerism between the USA and the world. Though there are people that do not believe in god. That does not mean we need to give in to jut the gifts. It is about the meaning of being with family and the time spent with each other. Showing love and being there for are love ones but not just with gifts.
My family is always doing something big and tradition is the main thing. For my family and me we do believe in God and to give honor to God and to celebrate his birth. So that is a big part of my Christmas. This shows that we need to think more about are family and love ones and celebrate Christmas by showing love and not by the buying and the amazing gifts we must get.

Ariana m k00340946, CRN#31652

Abigail DeWitt

Christmas is not just another holiday, at least for my family. We also celebrate it to celebrate not just Jesus' birth, but also to be thankful for what He has done in our lives. It is also a great time to appreciate and enjoy family, not at all about the gifts, but more about showing our appreciation for the people in our lives, gifts just being only one way. I think that it is very important for people to realize WHAT they are celebrating, by celebrating Christmas, because it does have significance and meaning--it isn't just another holiday, it's a time to be thankful that we have a savior.

Daniel Rodriguez

To answer your main questions, yes as a Roman Catholic I do think that it is important to know the meaning of certain holidays, especially Christmas. I also certainly agree with you when you talk about how much consumerism has become so central to the celebration of Christmas. While I do think that consumerism is not the "true meaning" of Christmas, I do think that the consumer culture is important in one way - to help families stay in close contact with each other. True, money and gifts are only material things, and Christmas is not just about materialism, but from my experience, hanving gifts and presents over the holidays can, in turn, help people appreciate non-material aspects of life,like family religion and love.

Juvaye Lindsey

i agree with some of the feedback. Christmas is a holdiay. Its souppose to be a celebration of Jesus Christ's birth. I often think that as people, we tend to forget what Christmas is because we get so side-tracked by the gifts etc. In my opinion During Christmas, your suppose to spend time with your family and/or loved ones and reminisce on the birth of Jesus Christ and all the things he endured. Its a holdiay where your suppose to give thanks. Im not saying that you cant recieve presents and gifts, but thats not what Christmas was made for. I feel like we need to also remember why we have Christmas. Me and my family are very relgious and we believe in Jesus Christ, God and the Holy Spirit, but at the same time we have gifts during this holiday, we dont base the holiday just on the opening of gifts though. All im stating is that dont forget the real reason why we have Christmas, its not for presents or gifts, but celebrating the day Jesus Christ was born.

Victor Ovalle

I absolutely agree with this post. growing up and coming into college i ask myself the same thing, being more analytical i suppose; Why do we celebrate Christmas? i dont think that there is the right answer, maybe to me. What i do know is that i celebrate it and that i like celebrating it. Eating with the family, shopping for gifts and receiving gifts, and being all together, is one of the reasons why i think that we celebrate Christmas.

Alana

Christmas is not soley a Christian event, and many of the elements of the occassion come from elsewhere. The "celebration" element of it; dinners, parties, etc, come from Pagan festivals when the winter solstice was celebrated. The "Christmas" we celebrate today is a mixture of pagan, christian and other influences, including what you have mentioned: consumerism.
Consumerism plays a HUGE role in Christmas, as you mentioned a large portion of stores income come from this time of year and there is always that 'Christmas rush' that takes over big stores every year.
If you take out the presents and the religious elements of it...really it should be about family and friends. Coming together to spend some quality time together. Honestly I think people also just enjoy the time off work or away from school.
Christmas means a lot of different things to a lot of different people...depending on what influences them. If they are religious they will probably see it as a religious occassion just as well as if they are not they will see it as something else: important for family, gifts...whatever.
For me, Christmas has been a time when I get to see my family...and I wouldn't say that it has brought us closer together or anything as we still ONLY see them at that time. Really, it IS a lot about the presents. When I was younger it might've been the 'magic' of it...Santa Claus and the lot...but now, sadly, I would say the magic of Christmas has dwindled and mostly...its just another day that I don't have to be in school for.

Lekeya Jackson

I celebrate this not because of religious reasons but because of traditional reasons my family and I share. It's just how I grow up having a tree and buy gifts for one another. It's just something we do and that I pass along to my children.

Marty Denton

I believe in the celebration of the life of Jesus Christ, Christmas is an will always be to me a joyful day of being with ones family and the observance of the birth of Christ,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElDab5Tf9Gs

Faith

Last minute crowds shopping for Christmas can be fun for some people and just annoying to other people. Some people see the crowds as a challenge to see if they can get what they want and get out in a timely fashion. Though other people just want for everyone to get out of there way and if they don't there will be a fight. Though Christmas crowds want several things in common to get what their person wanted, get a sale, and get out before Christmas morning.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

May 2012

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    

Search Everyday Sociology Blog

Interested in submitting a guest post?

If you're a sociology instructor or student and would like us to consider your guest post for everydaysociologyblog.com please .

Norton Sociology Books

Introduction to Sociology

Learn More

The Real World

Learn More

You May Ask Yourself

Learn More

Essentials of Sociology

Learn More

Everyday Sociology Reader

Learn More

The Contexts Reader

Learn More

Become a Fan

NYT > Sociology