October 20, 2011

Smiling and Status

ksternheimerBy Karen Sternheimer

I recently had the privilege of undergoing a root canal.

I mean that only semi-sarcastically; the procedure was not exactly fun, nor how I would have hoped to spend the morning, and it wasn’t cheap. That’s where privilege comes into play.

Having a good paying job and dental insurance meant that I could undergo the procedure, sparing me the possibility of chronic pain and infection. The reason I went to the dentist in the first place was to get my routine six-month cleaning, which thanks to my insurance and socio-economic status is something I can afford to do regularly. clip_image002[5]

 

I had no symptoms, no toothache that might have led me for a visit otherwise. But after taking X-rays, my dentist saw that decay had spread into the dentin, and without a root canal the tooth could become infected.

This came as a surprise to me; not only do I go for my professional cleanings religiously, I brush my teeth three times a day and always floss. People who know me were shocked that I could need a root canal. So while personal failure could contribute to tooth decay, even someone who follows the rules may need serious dental work from time to time.

Let’s imagine I had no dental insurance, and maybe a job that didn’t pay as well. Especially since I felt fine, I might have skipped the visit and figured that all was well and I would only go in if I felt pain. By that time, I might have an abscess or an infection that could make the procedure far more painful. clip_image002

Someone who can’t afford the treatment might just have their tooth pulled, making it harder to chew. After the treatment that part of my mouth was so sore I had to avoid chewing there, but it least it was temporary—and the teeth on the other side of my mouth are all intact, so I could still eat whatever I wanted, just carefully.

Teeth are more than just functional tools for eating; they are markers of status. Having straight, white teeth is about more than health, but connotes one’s class status as well, regardless of age. While I never had to wear braces, many kids I went to school with did. I’m sure they weren’t thrilled to wear them, but they had the benefit of straight teeth later in life. Children in less affluent families may not get braces because they might be too expensive, physically marking their status for years to come if their teeth are very crooked.

Sociologists Susan Starr Sered and Rushika Fernandopulle, authors “Sick out of Luck”, describe how inadequate access to health care not only creates physical problems for lower income individuals, but because these problems can be visible—like missing teeth—we have in effect created a caste system, where status becomes a visible marker. Imagine the challenges someone missing several teeth might find getting a job, especially one at a managerial level.

Some people who have health insurance at their job do not have dental insurance. According to a study released in 2010, approximately one in four Americans under 65 had no dental insurance in 2008. The study found that dental coverage was related to education and income; about 40 percent of those without a high school degree had no dental insurance.

Adults over the age of 21 poor enough to qualify for Medicaid (each state has its own guidelines and income limits) can get dental treatment in emergency situations in some states, but not most. States that do provide some coverage generally do not cover basic preventative care. People under 21 receiving Medicaid generally do receive dental care as part of the State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), but these programs have been the victim of recent budget cuts, and many states have made it harder to qualify for them.

Of course the most serious dental problems tend to happen as people get older, so you might be surprised to learn that Medicare (government health insurance for Americans 65 and over) only covers emergency procedures like reconstructing a jaw after an accident if it is considered “an integral part … of a covered procedure.” In other words, if someone has a tumor in their jaw that would be covered, but the plan explicitly excludes dentures:

Medicare does not make payment for the cost of dental appliances, such as dentures, even though the covered service resulted in the need for the teeth to be replaced, the cost of preparing the mouth for dentures, or the cost of directly repairing teeth or structures directly supporting teeth.

Low-income people might find themselves at the mercy of clinics with limited hours or go to dental schools for discounted services. As a graduate student, I once had my teeth cleaned by a dental student. That experience alone could have soured me from regular dental care, had I not had prior experiences with seasoned dentists.

At the school’s clinic I had to wait quite a while in the lobby before going to two different places, one for X-rays and one for the cleaning, which all told took about three hours (I am in and out in under an hour in my current dentist’s office). The student frequently drew blood while cleaning my teeth, something that never happened before or since.

It’s interesting to consider why dental coverage seldom comes up in conversations about health care reform. After all, teeth are body parts we use regularly. Without them, we would have trouble eating healthy foods (like crunchy vegetables), and they can be gateways to infections. Gum disease has been associated with heart disease, the leading cause of death in the U.S.

I will soon return to the dentist to have a crown placed on the tooth that had the root canal. Am I looking forward to it? Not really. But I’m very fortunate to have the opportunity to receive proper dental care, which both reflects and replicates my socio-economic status.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83534ac5b69e2014e8b69a91c970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Smiling and Status:

Comments

It's great that you have a dental insurance. A lot of people forego visiting the dentist because they are afraid of the experience or they find the expenses overwhelming. Dental care is truly a privilege that we enjoy.

Why is that, the most powerful country on earth can’t afford to pay for preventive care for every citizen on this free land, but they can afford to pay for wars? How great it is when you are one of those few lucky people who enjoy the privilege of dental insurance and have a well pay job. What can you do for the best of the majority interest if you are one of those who live without insurance?

When we commit to smiling by our demeanour, even when things are tough, and to fight for understanding, when all is confused, we are on the path to peace. When we can smile when we don't want to, and choose to understand when we don't, then we know we want peace. Peace can be a hard thing, but it's really an easy thing.

It is hard to believe that today, if we have a setback and lose our job we could lose everything, our income, our health benefits, possibly the roof over our head, and even our level of social standing. I agree with Ms. Sternheimer, dental coverage should be included in health care reform, and should include mental, physical, dental and especially preventive measures. We should start with those that have the least and who would probably appreciate it the most by having something, rather than nothing. The "little guy", the working poor and underclass, should be given some of the benefits, rather than the wealthy at the top. It would be great to have the government encourage and reward companies for staying and producing products to generate jobs and prosperity in our own United States. This country has people looking for work that would like to have the opportunity to earn an income, allowing them to have health insurance and to pay for the needs of their families. I applaud Ms. Sternheimer for giving hope that others will become aware of the inequality in health care opportunities for those having lower socioeconomic status in the United States.

Dental problems without insurance of some kind is a nightmare!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Become a Fan

The Society Pages Community Blogs

Interested in Submitting a Guest Post?

If you're a sociology instructor or student and would like us to consider your guest post for everydaysociologyblog.com please .

Norton Sociology Books

You May Ask Yourself

Learn More

Essentials of Sociology

Learn More

The Family

Learn More

The Real World

Learn More

Introduction to Sociology

Learn More

The Everyday Sociology Reader

Learn More

« Sampling Bias and Twitter | Main | Class Segregation in Academia »