March 10, 2014

Peace and Friendship in Crimea

Peter_kaufmanBy Peter Kaufman

If you have been following the news you have probably heard a lot about Crimea. I’m guessing that many Americans had (or maybe still have) no idea where Crimea is or why we should care about it.

This has not been the case for me. Whenever I think of Crimea I always think of peace and friendship. Such a sentiment may seem rather odd given the current geo-political strife that is confronting that region of the world. With Vladimir Putin flexing his military muscles and President Obama spewing threatening cease and desist warnings, peace and friendship are not the keywords that one currently associates with Crimea.

My connection to the Crimean peninsula dates back a little over twenty-five years ago when I worked as a camp counselor in the summer of 1988 at Artek. Artek was a famous Young Pioneers camp situated on the Black Sea in the small town of Hurzuf (or Gurzuf as it is sometimes written) just down the road from the historically significant city of Yalta. The camp hosted children from around the world as a way to promote peace, friendship, and intercultural understanding.

Crimeamap
Source: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Crimeamap.png

 My summer adventure in Artek actually began in the winter of 1987 when I participated in a sister-city program and traveled to four cities in the then-Soviet Union: Moscow, Saint Petersburg (which at the time was known as Leningrad), Kiev, and Kisinev. From contacts I made on this trip, I learned about the summer camp at Artek and found out that an American delegation of children was planning to attend the following summer. I sent in my application to be a counselor and much to my delight I was chosen to be one of eight group leaders who would be traveling with over 100 children from the United States.

398px-RIAN_archive_171678_All-Union_'Artek'_Camp_buglers
Source: RIA Novosti archive, image #171678 / Vladimir Fedorenko / CC-BY-SA 3.0

I had worked at summer camps for a number of years but nothing could prepare me for what I experienced at Artek. Spread over nearly 5 miles along the beautiful Black Sea coast, Artek is actually comprised of ten small camps.  Our delegation of 100 was divided into four groups, each being housed in a separate camp with campers from around the world. In my camp, we had kids from Nicaragua, Canada, Finland, India, Vietnam, France, Cuba, Lebanon, Germany, and Burundi. Half of each camp was also comprised of kids from all over the Soviet Union. While most of our day revolved around typical summer camp activities such as playing sports, swimming, singing, and socializing, there were also daily opportunities—both formal and informal—for cross-cultural dialogues and exchanges.

For me, these cross-cultural interactions were one of the highlights of my experience at Artek. Whether it was roof-top discussions with Sandinista kids from Nicaragua, cultural performances by children from Uzbekistan, or political discussions with my fellow counselors, these experiences always resulted in greater understanding and respect among the participants.

800px-RIAN_archive_872838_Children_at_the_Artek_Young_Pioneer_Camp
Source: RIA Novosti archive, image #872838 / Vladimir Rodionov / CC-BY-SA 3.0

I was at Artek when the Cold War was still quite chilly. Although there were some signs of defrosting, and the thaw was completed a few years later, the relationship between the American and Soviet governments was still tense.  As a political science and sociology undergrad, I found the political landscape fascinating; however, I was also somewhat perplexed by what I was experiencing at Artek. My political socialization taught me that the Soviet Union was the “evil empire” and that I should be wary of any and all things from this communist superpower.

At Artek, this dualistic or binary way of seeing the world was nowhere to be found. There was no talk of the United States or its allies being evil nor was there talk of the Soviets and their allies being superior. Instead, a genuine sense of harmony and cooperation was emphasized. In fact, the official chant of the camp was Artek! Mir! Druzhba! (Артек! мир! дружба!)—which roughly translates to Artek! Peace! Friendship! I would hear or see these three words everywhere I went.

Ceremony

Photo courtesy of the author

As I follow the current events unfold in Crimea, and with talk increasing each day of a “new Cold War” between Russia and United States, I can’t help but think back to the lessons that were being taught at Artek. It seems tragically ironic that not too far from where armies are drawing lines in the sand and people are choosing sides and loyalties, there is a place where individuals recognize and embrace their commonalties instead of emphasize and exacerbate their differences.

I would love for the major players in the Crimean conflict to take a short bus trip over to Artek and spend a week or so as typical campers.  I know this idea sounds naïve and idealistic but there is actually a sociological basis for suggesting it. According to the Thomas Theorem, if people define situations as real they are real in their consequences. In other words, the way in which we define the situation has implications for what we believe and how we behave.

In the case of Crimea, the situation is defined in stark dualistic terms: Russia versus Ukraine, which is really an outgrowth of the larger duality of the U.S./Western influence versus Russian influence. Given this definition, it is not surprising that we see escalating tensions as each side feels it must stay committed to the way they have defined the reality.

Crimea friendship

Photo courtesy of the author

At Artek, the social landscape was defined quite differently; as a result, there were very different consequences. Instead of promulgating a dualistic sense of reality in which individuals had to pledge their allegiance to one side or another, the idea of interdependence was promoted—both in words and in deeds. There was a sincere feeling among those of us at Artek that peace was possible. Indeed, as the Thomas Theorem suggests, if you spend the summer with people from around the world chanting and singing about peace and friendship then it’s hard not embrace this worldview.  As I said, I know what I’m saying may come off as naïve and idealistic but it certainly seems more sane and less frightening then the way the situation is being defined and handled today.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83534ac5b69e201a73d8a3d39970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Peace and Friendship in Crimea:

Comments

These are great news,hope the friendship will last a long,long time.People they are destroying this planet with their greed.

In my believe (i'm from the Netherlands) we are partly "brainwashed" by America. Migt be wrong to say this openly. I think the TV is controlled by America, even here. We never see the side of other countries. We never see the sight of Russia/ Ukraine. We never saw the sight of Irac, Iran or .. We follow America in whatever they say. We make the tensions, i agree. Maybe we are even the ones who make the whole wars..

I don't know what to believe anymore these days. I don't know who is good and who is wrong, if we should mengle or not..

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Become a Fan

The Society Pages Community Blogs

Interested in Submitting a Guest Post?

If you're a sociology instructor or student and would like us to consider your guest post for everydaysociologyblog.com please .

Norton Sociology Books

You May Ask Yourself

Learn More

Essentials of Sociology

Learn More

The Family

Learn More

The Real World

Learn More

Introduction to Sociology

Learn More

The Everyday Sociology Reader

Learn More

« Why My Paper is Late: Excuses and Justifications | Main | Gentrification in Spike Lee’s Old Neighborhood »