Racism in Toyland

By Karen Sternheimer

You have probably heard critics of Barbie decry the unrealistic beauty image the toy reflects. I’m guessing you may have already thought about the way that children’s toys promote somewhat rigid gender identities. But have you ever thought about how toys reflect racial inequality?

During the holiday shopping season, a friend of mine went to buy a doll for her daughter. She had a coupon for a specific doll from the  newspaper circular, and she was excited because she knew that particular doll also came in a black version. Since her daughter is multiracial, she likes her to have dolls of many hues to play with.

But when she went to check out, she was told that the coupon was only valid on the white doll.

Now there might be marketing reasons that the coupon could only work with the white doll; the UPC code might have been different on the black doll. Maybe they had an abundance of white dolls that the store was looking to move off of the shelves. Since the manufacturer probably produces so many more white versions of the doll and the retailer also probably buys a whole lot more of the white ones, it makes sense from a business perspective that one version would be cheaper to clear inventory. Ultimately, the store manager refused to honor the coupon (which did not say was for white dolls only).

But from a sociological standpoint, the price difference is a surcharge for black dolls which could work to deter customers from buying one. According to the U.S. Census, the median household income for African Americans is approximately 61% of white, non-Hispanic households. This income disparity makes it even more of a burden to pay more for essentially the same doll. 

Since the middle of the last century, toy manufacturers have come a long way. Dora the Explorer is an extremely popular Latina television character (with requisite doll and other toys). Fisher Price's Little People toys also feature children clearly from multiple ethnic groups. American Girl dolls are mostly white, but their Mexican American, Native American and African American dolls aren’t segregated on their homepage, as they are on www.toysrus.com. If you visit this site and click on dolls, they have many categories to choose from, including "ethnic dolls". Even many of those dolls appear to be white or very light skinned. 

This separate category literally segregates dolls of color…except most of these dolls at best look like white people with deep tans. Of those slightly darker in color, they often have Caucasian-like hair and even blue eyes. 

There’s another curious thing about the “ethnic” category: it presumes that “ethnic” only refers to people who are not white in appearance. The other dolls are just dolls.

This designation reflects the way in which people classified as “white” today are often viewed as “non-ethnic,” when by definition everyone has an ethnicity. As Janis Prince Inniss previously blogged about, ethnicity refers to cultural practices, custom, language, and ancestry. It is not insignificant that some groups become seen as “normal” and others “ethnic”. And it is not insignificant that dolls reflect this inequality.

You might be familiar with a famous experiment from 1954, where a psychologist found that black girls chose white dolls more often than black dolls. This study influenced the Supreme Court’s landmark Brown v. Board of Education decision that same year, as the high court interpreted this experiment to mean that these children had internalized racism, and that segregation’s psychological effects needed to be reversed.

A high school student replicated this experiment with 21 girls in New York in 2005 and found similar results, which received national attention. 

Certainly self-esteem issues are important. But we often overlook the role the toy industry plays in shaping which dolls seem “better” to children of all racial/ethnic backgrounds. It is obviously not enough just to have “ethnic” dolls available (albeit this is a major step forward from the 1954 experiment when likely very few were widely available).

When dolls are segregated in the stores or are simply colored-in versions of other dolls, it sends a message that they are less desirable. In one store my friend visited, she saw no non-white dolls and asked whether they carried any. The clerk told her that they had black Cabbage Patch dolls, but they were in the storeroom and that she would gladly go to get her one. 

While it would be illegal to require a black person to eat their lunch only in a restaurant’s kitchen or sit on the back of the bus today, it isn’t illegal to segregate dolls. But it does communicate their inferior status.

Sociologist Christine L. Williams conducted ethnographic research in toy stores, which she describes in her book Inside Toyland: Working, Shopping, and Social Inequality. Williams worked as a clerk and was able to interact with both shoppers and store management. 

She notes that in the big box store where she worked, black children (and often their families) were frequently considered shoplifters, particularly if staff members (of all races) thought they appeared to be low-income. When they entered toy stores, they were clearly less-than welcome. In contrast, rules were often bent for white middle class female shoppers and clerks were expected to provide them with a significant level of service.

Williams noticed that African American shoppers were given less attention than white shoppers. If they got angry they were not appeased by staff, as their white counterparts often were, but instead might be told to leave the store. In some cases the police were even called.

Toys are social manifestations of many things: they represent collective (although contested) ideas of how children should play; their presentation and marketing reflects notions of value, and their purchase reflects and reinforces inequality.

Comments

[Patti]

Unfortunately racism still exists, and Toyland is no exception.

To help combat this problem, two Ethiopian born women developed ethidolls.com, the first educational, authentic, collectible quality dolls celebrating African women leaders from history.

The first in their series, Makeda (R), The Queen of Sheba Doll, represents the first woman ruler of Ethiopia, comes with her own storybook and audio CD narration which tell of her rise to the throne and her legendary journey to visit King Solomon. She wears authentic Ethiopian attire whose fabric was hand-woven in Ethiopia and has the traditional neck tattoo still worn by Ethiopian women today.

The second offering available in May 2008 will be Queen Mother, Yaa Asantewaa from Ghana, a celebrated icon and woman of distinction whose singular act of bravery in 1900 catapulted her to international fame.

EthiDolls aims to contribute to changing the ubiquitous negative images of Africa by offering positive role models, through dolls, books and CDs, based on historic African women leaders. EthiDolls hopes to awaken this same spirit of leadership in today's young African-American girls and their multicultural playmates by offering a new vision of the African experience. The company wants these girls and the world at large to know that Africa has a rich history of accomplishment and dignity, and that African women in particular have played an important role.

Visit www.ethidolls.com to learn more about the company and its products.

[Steve O]

There's a movie with John Travolta and Harry Belafonte called "White Man's Burden." In a kind of breaching experiment sort of way the movie "shocks" people into seeing the everyday privileges of skin color. Instead of portraying white dominance though, it offers a world where African Americans control society and define value and desire. Cops are black and police poor white neighborhoods where they are hated by the residents. Harry Belafonte is an executive in a company where the upper-management is composed of mostly black men. One of the most memorable moments for me in this movie is when John Travolta's character is driving with his son (I'm guessing he's about 8 years old) and they stop at a toy store. Travolta tells his son to pick out a toy and he picks up a black doll. Travolta asks his son what's wrong with the white doll and why he doesn't want it, but the son insists on having the black doll. It's a great way of illuminating how we construct and internalize value through largely white eyes.

[Karen Sternheimer]

Steve, that movie sounds like a great example. I'll have to check it out! And Patti, thanks for posting the site for EthiDolls. I think a lot of people looking for alternatives to the big box stores' toy selection will be interested in them.

[Jaida M]

I agree with Karen Sternheimer’s article because I have also noticed that most shopping malls tend to provide more light skinned dolls rather than dark. After reading this article it made me think about the racial inequality that is going on. This segregation of dolls is not very far from the segregation of people, which not that long ago existed in the United States. I’m a bit confused about the famous experiment in 1954 because I don’t understand why African American children would rather play with white dolls? I would have thought children would want to play with dolls of their own race. That test might explain why some stores make more white dolls than dark. Personally I think there should be an equal number of different racial dolls no matter what the circumstances. And when it comes to African American’s not as welcome in a toy store, that’s ridiculous. Everyone should be treated the same when entering a store. I believe it’s true when Sternheimer says, “…their purchase reflects and reinforces inequality.”
I hope this issue isn’t going to be long term and I really hope people start realizing the effects it will cause in the future if something doesn’t change now.

[Lisa]

these dolls sound like a great way to educate our children about other races - but what the last commenter forgot to mention is that these ethidolls are $140 + $25 for the audio book! no thanks...

[Brenda]

Racism in toy stores! wow! Who would have ever thought of that. When I was small I remember going into the toy stores with my parents over 40 years ago and differenciating between African American, Latino, Asian or Caucasian dolls wasn't an issue to me. Back in those days, no matter what color you were, it was a blessing to even get a doll and color wasn't an issue. What amazes me is, everyone on the face of this earth was created equal and to dwell on a certain color within an ethnic group is just showing your ignorance of how uninformed about society and love for your country you really are. Additionally, you would think as hard as times are today no one should just be focusing on color, especially on something so juvenile as an doll color. No matter what ethnic background you are when you wake up in the morning and go to work and get paid what ever your race is the money is green, ever race spends green money. Why isn't money a racial issue? Let's focus on bigger things like world peace, our troops, the oil spill,etc.

[michelle ansley]

Responding to Jada's comments:
I remember doing research back in highschool about the girls choosing white dolls vs. "colored dolls" or "black dolls". It was to prove a point that racism was more or less scarring young children by making them think that the "colored dolls" (the same race as the children) were not as pretty or as nice as the white dolls. It showed their view of their own self esteem. it was along the time of separate but equal issues i do believe...not completely positive. the results showed that most chose the white dolls thinking they were special or prettier than the others, and that they didnt want to play with the black dolls due to depression, anger, and resentment.

[michelle ansley]

I personally agree that there is a racism and a gender issue as well in stores, esp. in Walmart. I personally purchase every year for my daughter, a Holiday series Barbie doll. Usually, the white dolls are either hard to find due to selling out so quickly (could be due to the fact that when Barbie originally began, it was an "all white" icon) and the left over boxes are usu. the african american dolls and the boxes are dented. When stock is in supply, the number of causcasian dolls out weigh the african american dolls by far. I believe that the Barbie icon is just as guilty as the stores for the fact that in order to boost their sales, they have begun to offer such collections as "Dolls around the world" which include: Spain, Ireland, and other regions. The fact that they have offered the other cultures is great, but they dont put as much emphasis on the cultural dolls as much as they do the traditional "white barbie" and the american icons such as Elvis, Marilyn Monroe,and Cher barbies. Walmart has also made a point to carry more clothing and shoe varieties for girls than they do for boys. This is also the same in the situation for the Ken Barbie dolls, they are very limited and often hard to find. I have 2 boys and 1 daughter, i find it really hard to dress my children with reasonable choices and its very easy to shop for my daughter due to the partiality and favortism shown.

[Brandi Mackey]

I think that toys can certainly create some racial inequality. Just take a look at barbie dolls and what not, most of them have been white for a while, it wasn't until about 10 years ago when they started making more black dolls. I am glad that they finally did, but you will still notice a lack of ethnicticity when you look down the toy isle, and still has a WORLD of improvement to make. I think there is a huge market out there for more ethnic toys, if someone would just start making them, I 100% believe that they would have a crowd to sell to.

[Beverly Gray]

it is not fair that the coupon did not work for the darker-skinned doll!!!! It's almost as if she was being penalizded because of her skin color!!

[Toys]

While there has been no specific research on the phenomenon of women owning lifelike doll babies, I am glad to weigh in on the psychological underpinnings. People often have a negative reaction when they hear about these lifelike babies, sometimes called “reborn” babies or “memory” babies. It’s typical to think something is weird or creepy when it’s unknown, far from the norm, or common only to a different culture.